The Global Think Tank - Click here to learn more...

Pro et Contra : Pro et Contra

The quarterly journal Pro et Contra is devoted to topical Russian and international issues. The journal publishes articles by prominent Russian and international experts, political analysts, economists and sociologists. As a forum for free discussion on key aspects of modern public life, Pro et Contra offers readers a diverse analysis of domestic and foreign policy, the economy, international relations, public life and political institutions. Pro et Contra's chief editor is Maria Lipman, a well-known journalist and specialist on domestic policy and civil society issues.
  • Pro et Contra

    Twenty Years Without Soviet Power

    Boris Dubin, Clifford Gaddy, Barry Ickes, Alexander Zaslavsky, Nikolay Petrov, Michael Dobbs, David Remnick, Stephen Hanson, Alexander Kustarev, Igor Fediukin, Boris Makarenko, Konstantin von Eggert Volume 15, Issue 5, September-October 2011

    In the wake of the twentieth anniversary of the collapse of Soviet communism, the authors of this issue examine aspects of post-Soviet development, including public opinion, the economy, and the state, and how they have evolved over the course of the past twenty years.

  • Pro et Contra

    Post-Soviet Political Systems

    Andrei Ryabov, Alexander Iskandaryan, Grigory Ioffe, Nicu Popescu, Olexiy Haran, Alexey Malashenko, Ivan Krastev, Olga Malinova, Evgeny Finkel, Maciej Janowski, Walter Laqueur, Viktor Shnirelman, Sergey Kravchenko Volume 15, Issue 3-4, May-August 2011

    While new nation- and state-building processes in the former Soviet Union draw opportunistically on their Soviet heritage, a new nationalism is bringing the states of the region inexorably further from each other and their shared past.

  • Pro et Contra

    Russia-2020. Part II

    Sam Greene, Lev Gudkov, Jens Siegert, Natalia Zubarevich, Vladimir Milov, Daniel Treisman, Dmitri Trenin, Filipp Chapkovskiy, Mary McAuley, Alexander Kustarev, Sergey Golunov, Sergey Peregudov Volume 15, Issue 1-2, January-April 2011

    Participants of “Russia-2020” project continue to explore the factors that shape Russia’s development, the various crossroads that lie ahead, and the risks that Russia may face.

  • Pro et Contra

    Russia-2020

    Kirill Rogov, Vladimir Gelman, Boris Makarenko, Alexander Golts, Igor Zevelev, Robert Orttung, Alexey Malashenko, Thomas Graham, Arkady Moshes, Christian Caryl Volume 14, Issue 4-5, July-October 2010

    Political analysts from Russia and abroad discuss the outlook for Russia ten years down the road and endeavor to outline the potential for development in social, economic, and political life.

  • Pro et Contra

    Education Reform: Projects and Prospects

    Vadim Radaev, Igor Fediukin, Isak Froumin, Boris Dubin, Harley Balzer, Timothy O’Connor, Natalia Zubarevich, Oleg Podvintsev, Thomas de Waal, Konstantin von Eggert Volume 14, Issue 3, May-June 2010

    In order for Russia’s university education system to promote the country’s development and its stature among leading world powers, there must be a modernizing shift in the mindset of the Russian people.

  • Pro et Contra

    The Emergence of a Civic Culture of Parenthood

    Maria Mayofis, Ilya Kukulin, Stanislav Lvovskiy, Svetlana Korolyova, Alexey Levinson, Olga Sveshnikova, Ekaterina Asonova, Galina Karpova, David Hoffman, Anton Oleynik, Alexey Makarkin, Alexander Kustarev, Konstantin von Eggert, Igor Fedyukin, Dmitri Trenin Volume 14, Issue 1-2, January-April 2010

    With the creation of independent associations, both virtual and real, for parents to find help and support without recourse to the state, the development of new practices of parenthood is quietly helping to undermine statist paternalism.

  • Pro et Contra

    The Crisis as a Point of Departure

    Kirill Rogov, Nikolay Petrov, Vladimir Gelman, Andrei Ryabov, Anton Oleynik, Dmitri Trenin, Alexander Kustarev, Timothy Garton Ash, Viktor Sheinis, Andrew Wilson, Mikhail Vashchenko, Sergey Panarin Volume 13, Issue 5-6, September-December 2009

    The global economic crisis has thus far had little effect on the existing political system in Russia, but the serious discussion it has provoked suggests that change may be inevitable.

  • Pro et Contra

    The Politics of History

    Alexey Miller, Georgiy Kasianov, Robert Traba, Olga Borokh, Alexander Lomanov, Jutta Scherrer, Alexander Astrov, Irina Busygina, Mikhail Filippov, Thomas Carothers Volume 13, Issue 3-4, May-August 2009

    In the post-socialist countries of Europe, governments have been employing historical narratives to achieve political ends. In central and eastern Europe, history is abused to create anti-Russian nationalism, while in Russia, defense of the official version of Soviet history means turning a blind eye to the crimes of the communist regime.

  • Pro et Contra

    Afghanistan as an International Problem

    Alexey Malashenko, Gilles Dorronsoro, Najeeb ur Rahman Manalai, Martha Brill Olcott, Evgeniy Pakhomov, Mark Kramer, Floriana Fossato, Andrei Ryabov, Aleksandr Kustaryov, Andrew Kuchins, Nikolay Pobol, Pavel Polyan Volume 13, Issue 2, March–April 2009

    The current American military campaign in Afghanistan enjoys broad international support, including from Russia. Yet despite this support, international experts remain focused on the likelihood of failure in Afghanistan rather than potential pathways for peaceful development.

  • Pro et Contra

    Politics Beyond the Political

    Boris Dubin, Il’ya Kukulin, Yulia Liderman, Alexey Makarkin, Alexander Golts, Edward Chow, Jonathan Elkind, Viktor Sheinis Volume 13, Issue 1, January–February 2009

    Russia’s political stability depends on civic and social fragmentation, which isolates groups from one another and, although not overtly political, has distinct political ramifications.

  • Pro et Contra

    Two Crises: Consequences and Outlook

    Nikolay Petrov, Dmitri Trenin, Boris Makarenko, Natalia Zubarevich, Mikhail Vinogradov, Vadim Volkov, Alexey Malashenko Volume 12, Issue 5-6, September-December 2008

    The economic crisis has brought to light the problems that arise from the concentration of power and deterioration of institutions in Russia. As resources diminish, the mechanisms of the state are increasingly becoming exhausted, demonstrating the need for political reform.

  • Pro et Contra

    Iran and Its Leaders

    Karim Sadjadpour, Elena Dunaeva, Anoush Ehteshami, Alexander Lukoyanov, Rose Gottemoeller, Alexander Lukin Volume 12, Issue 4, July–August 2008

    Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad has failed to improve the lives of ordinary Iranians and faces popular dissatisfaction with Iran’s economic problems. With his term due to end in June 2009, the opposition has an opening with the voters.

  • Pro et Contra

    New Forms of Civic Activism in Russia

    Tatiana Vorozheikina, Sam Greene, Graeme Robertson, Svetlana Solodovnik, Alexei Levinson, Anton Oleynik, Ekaterina Demintseva, Igor Feduikin, Mikhail Berger, Olga Proskurnina Volume 12, Issue 2-3, March-June 2008

    While grassroots activism is increasing in Russia, it is entirely divorced from politics. Russian citizens do not seem to view their political rights as a tool for resolving social problems, and there seems to be little outcry at the gradual erosion of these rights.

  • Pro et Contra

    Elections and Democracy

    Henry Hale, Grigory Golosov, Alexey Makarkin, Andrey Gomberg, Andrew Monaghan, Robert Reich, Stefan Theil Volume 12, Issue 1, January-February 2008

    Ruling elites in the former Soviet Union and elsewhere use elections to maintain the appearance of democracy, while working behind the scenes to neutralize their political opponents in an attempt to prevent any challenge to their political monopoly.

  • Pro et Contra

    Evolution of the World Order

    Alexander Kustarev, Robert Kagan, Olga Borokh, Alexander Lomanov, Andrew Kuchins, Alexander Lukin, Louise Richardson, David Bosco Volume 11, Issue 6, November-December 2007

    The hegemonic status of the United States is waning, as the international system transitions from unipolar to multipolar. However, this shift in the global balance of power provides no guarantees of a more peaceful new world order.

  • Pro et Contra

    Successor's Burden

    Nikolay Petrov, Kirill Rogov, Aleksey Makarkin, Mikhail Krasnov, Boris Makarenko, Vladimir Ryzhkov, Alexei Titkov, Leonid Grigor'ev, Andrey Yakovlev, Timothy M. Frye, Vladimir Milov, Evgeny Gontmaher Volume 11, Issue 4-5, July-October 2007

    Russia's new head of state will inherit a number of serious problems that have accumulated while vast intellectual, financial, and administrative resources were invested in the construction of the Russian political system.

  • Pro et Contra

    Nation Building

    Alexei Miller, Valery Tishkov, Emil Pain, Olga Malinova, Alexander Kustarev, Lev Gudkov, Boris Dubin, Pankaj Ghemawat Volume 11, Issue 3, May-June 2007

    Having no experience in free intellectual discourse on the development of national identity, Russia now faces the challenge of developing a civic nation, based on the active participation of citizens with general confidence in their nation's political institutions.

  • Pro et Contra

    Russian-American Relations

    Dmitri Trenin, Maksim Blant, Ksenia Yudaeva, Konstantin Kozlov, Sergei Guriev, Rose Gottemoeller, Aleksei Levinson, Javier Corrales, Daniel P. Erikson, Adam Minson, Igor Fediukin, Grigory Ioffe Volume 11, Issue 2, March-April 2007

    Relations between Russia and the United States have increasingly been limited to statements of mutual discontent. Yet this tension is entirely surmountable, and a consolidated relationship could do much to help solve pressing global dilemmas.

  • Pro et Contra

    Municipal Reform

    Vladimir Gelman, Aleksey Makarkin, Alexander Kynev, Maria Eismont, Leonid Smirnyagin, Alexander Puzanov, Lyudmila Ragozina, Thomas Carothers, George Perkovich Volume 11, Issue 1, January-February 2007

    Recent political developments in Russia have led to increased centralization of power, to the detriment of the political influence of local governments.

  • Pro et Contra

    Post-Soviet Conflicts

    Dmitri Trenin, Igor Fediukin, Andrei Ryabov, Nicu Popescu, Anna Tolkacheva, Alexander Golts, Alexey Malashenko, Aleksander Smolar Volume 10, Issue 5-6, September-December 2006

    In recent years, rapid change has come to the unrecognized and contested states in the territory of the former Soviet Union, such as Kosovo, Abkhazia, and South Ossetia. These changes are the result of significant shifts in the foreign policy of Russia and other former Soviet states.

 
Subscribe to Pro et Contra

Subscribe to <em>Pro et Contra</em> Use this form to subscribe to Pro et Contra — a quarterly public policy journal on topical Russian and international issues published by the Carnegie Moscow Center.

Editorial Staff
  • Maria Lipman

    Maria Lipman

    Editor-in-Chief

    Lipman has served as deputy editor of the Russian weekly newsmagazines, Ezhenedel’ny zhurnal and Itogi. She has worked as a translator, researcher, and contributor for the Washington Post's Moscow bureau and has had a monthly op-ed column in the Washington Post since 2001.

  •  
  • Alexander Starikov

    Associate Editor
  •  
  • Natalia Margolis

    Editor
  •  
  • Tatiana Barabanova

    Executive secretary
Information to Potential Authors

Average article length should not exceed 35 thousand characters. A copy of the author's resume in Russian (150 words) should be attached to the article.

Texts may be submitted by email, and must be in Word format. Notes must conform with the Russian standard (you may use the Notes to articles of the last issue #1, Vol. 9, 2005 as a sample).

Carnegie Global Experts Guide

Carnegie's enhanced expert guide allows visitors to navigate the global network of experts by:
 

Carnegie Moscow Center Resources

From Carnegie's Global Network

The Arab World's Education Report Card: School Climate and Citizenship Skills

Muhammad Faour
1/2/2012

Absent a good education environment, there is little room for the Arab world’s youth to turn into responsible citizens who can consolidate and stimulate social transformation to bring about more prosperous and free societies.

China-Latin American Relations: The End of the Honeymoon?

Matthew Ferchen
16/1/2012

An increasing trade deficit with China, coupled with Chinese purchases of large tracts of Latin American farmland, could cause strain between China and Latin American nations.

Strategic Europe

Jan Techau
25/1/2012

The obvious and often painful mismatch between aspiration and reality in European foreign policy has plagued discourse on European integration during the last decade.

Concern Elevates That Israel Will Strike Iran

Karim Sadjadpour
8/2/2012

As speculation increases that Iran is inching closer to acquiring nuclear weapons, rhetoric regarding war may just be an effort to strengthen diplomacy.

Connect with Carnegie Moscow

Stay in the Know

Sign up for Carnegie Moscow Center announcements and publications—including Carnegie Moscow Center Newsletter and Pro et Contra—by filling out the form below. Note—fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required.

Personal Information
Select topics & preferences
    Language Preference
    Regional Interests
    Policy Interests
 
 
Carnegie Moscow Center 16/2 Tverskaya Moscow, 125009 Russia Phone: +7 (495) 935-8904 Fax: +7 (495) 935-8906