Carnegie Moscow Center Carnegie Moscow Center

  • Global Resources

    Global Centers

    • Beijing
      • Home 中文
      • Issues 主题
      • Programs 项目
      • Experts 专家
      • Events 会议
      • Publications 出版物
      Shortcuts
      • For Media
      • Podcasts
      • Window Into China
    • Beirut
      • Home عربي
      • Issues القضايا
      • Regions المناطق
      • Experts الباحثون
      • Events الأنشطة
      • Publications المنشورات
      Shortcuts
      • Sada
      • Capacity Building
      • Syria in Crisis
      • For Media
    • Brussels
      • Home
      • Issues
      • Regions
      • Experts
      • Events
      • Publications
      • Publikationen auf deutsch Publications en français
      Shortcuts
      • Judy Dempsey’s Strategic Europe
      • For Media
    • Moscow
      • Home Главная страница
      • Programs Программы
      • Issues Темы
      • Experts Эксперты
      • Events События
      • Publications Публикации
      Shortcuts
      • For Media
    • Washington
      • Home
      • Issues
      • Regions
      • Publications
      • Experts
      • Events
      • Programs
      Shortcuts
      • Video
      • Infographics
      • For Media
      • For Government
      • For Academics

    Languages

    • English
      • Experts
      • Publications
      • Events
    • Русский
      • Эксперты
      • Публикации
      • События
    • 中文
      • 专家
      • 出版物
      • 会议
    • عربي
      • الباحثون
      • المنشورات
      • الأنشطة
  • Русский
  • Research
  • Events
  • Experts
  • Issues

WWII Anniversary Parade Snubs Push Moscow Diplomatic Shift

Source: Getty
Dmitri Trenin Op-Ed April 16, 2015 Global Times
Summary
On May 9—the Victory Day—the majority of top-level visitors will come to Moscow from the non-Western countries. Russia’s quest for acceptance in or by the West is finally over, and its foreign policy will require a new identity and new orientation.
Related Topics
  • Foreign and Security Policy
  • Asia-Pacific Security
  • New Cold War
  • Russian Ideology
Related Media and Tools
  • Print Page
 

Politics, including international relations, is about symbols as well as actions. When Russia staged the 2014 Winter Olympics in Sochi, it sought to present the image of a modern country, open to the world. Next month, when Russia will hold a military parade in Red Square to celebrate the 70th anniversary of victory in the Great Patriotic War against Nazi Germany, it will be restating its role in the allied victory in World War II. The USSR, which the present-day Russian Federation regards as its direct predecessor, lost at least 28 million people in that epic war.

Russians generally believe that their most valuable contribution to humanity was the defeat of Hitler's war machine. May 9, Victory Day, has been Russia's true, and truly sacred, national day, ever since 1945.

Trenin, director of the Carnegie Moscow Center, has been with the center since its inception. He also chairs the research council and the Foreign and Security Policy Program.
Dmitri Trenin
Director
Moscow Center
More from this author...
  • Russia Needs a Plan C
  • Turkish-Russian War of Words Goes Beyond Downed Plane
  • Putin’s Syria Gambit Aims at Something Bigger Than Syria
  • Like It or Not, America and Russia Need to Cooperate in Syria
@DmitriTrenin
Since the end of Cold War, the Kremlin has made a habit of inviting world leaders to the Victory Day anniversaries in Moscow.

In 1995, then US president Bill Clinton came to Moscow; in 2005, it was George W. Bush. In 2015, they invited Barack Obama. However, not only Obama is staying at home; with very few exceptions, Western leaders are collectively boycotting the event. This is a way for them to protest over Russia's actions in Crimea and its policies toward Ukraine.

The trend toward minimizing direct contacts with Vladimir Putin had been evident even before the Ukraine crisis. Most Western countries, led by the US, stayed away from the Sochi Olympics, censuring Russia for other transgressions, such as legislation banning gay "propaganda" to minors. In 2013, Obama, in an unprecedented step, canceled his official visit to Moscow, over the Snowden affair.

This tightening boycott illustrates the depth and breadth of the chasm now separating Russia and the West. To many ordinary Russians, the collective Western no-show is more than a sign of disapproval of their leader's policies. This is a slight against their most cherished national heritage. What is worse, they also hear that the West is supporting a Ukrainian leadership that formally equates communism with Nazism, and blames Stalin, alongside Hitler, for the outbreak of WWII.

As a result, common victory in WWII, which even during the highly ideological Cold War was recognized as a measure of the potential for Soviet-Western cooperation and a thus hope for a better future, is no longer shared.

On May 9, the lineup of Moscow's guests of honor will demonstrate the dramatic change in Russia's international position over the past 18 months. The two dozen or so top-level visitors will come mostly from the non-Western countries of Asia, Latin America, and Africa. Among them, Chinese President Xi Jinping will be the most prominent.

Russia's divorce from its Western partners will be clear for everyone to see. Even the German chancellor will pointedly avoid the Red Square parade, only to appear the following day for a wreath-laying ceremony.

The rupture is as much symbolic as it is real. Russia's quarter-century-long quest for acceptance in or by the West is finally over.

In 2014, the country returned to its traditional Eurasian posture, albeit no longer as an aspiring hegemon in either Europe or Asia. Solidifying relations with its partners in the region such as Armenia, Belarus, or Kazakhstan, will be very important, but the key relationship for Moscow in the foreseeable future will be that with Beijing.

In return for Xi's decision to visit Victory Day parade in Red Square, Putin will visit China to celebrate the event to mark the end of WWII in September, something no Russian or Soviet leader has done before. 

Russia's focus on the non-Western world is not limited to China, of course. Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev has recently completed a visit to Vietnam and Thailand, looking for economic opportunities in Southeast Asia. Kim Jong-un, the North Korean leader, is also expected to make it to Moscow on May 9. Ties to Turkey, Iran, Egypt and Syria are all being expanded. Two months after the parade in Red Square, Putin will be hosting back-to-back summits of BRICS and the Shanghai Cooperation Organization in Ufa.

Anniversaries, parades and even summits are mostly about public relations. However, beyond the fanfares, martial music and the roar of aircraft flying over Red Square, Russia's foreign policy will require a new identity and new orientation.

Having seen, in the past year, its Plan A, Western integration of Russia, fail and Plan B for Eurasian integration around Russia scaled down, Moscow will have to come up with a realistic Plan C, featuring a close and yet balanced partnership with China and expanded relations with non-Western countries around the world.

This article originally appeared in Global Times.

End of document
 
Source http://carnegie.ru/2015/04/16/wwii-anniversary-parade-snubs-push-moscow-diplomatic-shift/i7bw

More from The Global Think Tank

  • Publications
  • Events
  • Judy Asks: Should Western Leaders Attend Moscow’s WWII Parade?
  • National Interest
    Russia’s Missile Moves Explained: The S-300 Challenge
  • From Greater Europe to Greater Asia? The Sino-Russian Entente
  • Moscow
    Russia and the West: What Next?
  • Beijing
    China and Its Neighboring Countries: Big Data Illustrations
Twitter
@DmitriTrenin
@DmitriTrenin

Sign up for Carnegie Email

 
  • Connect With Us
  • Support The Global Think Tank
 
Carnegie Moscow Center
 
Please note...

You are leaving the Carnegie–Tsinghua Center for Global Policy's website and entering another Carnegie global site.

请注意...

你将离开清华—卡内基中心网站,进入卡内基其他全球中心的网站。