Carnegie Moscow Center Carnegie Moscow Center

  • Global Resources

    Global Centers

    • Beijing
      • Home 中文
      • Issues 主题
      • Programs 项目
      • Experts 专家
      • Events 会议
      • Publications 出版物
      Shortcuts
      • For Media
      • Podcasts
      • Window Into China
    • Beirut
      • Home عربي
      • Issues القضايا
      • Regions المناطق
      • Experts الباحثون
      • Events الأنشطة
      • Publications المنشورات
      Shortcuts
      • Sada
      • Capacity Building
      • Syria in Crisis
      • For Media
    • Brussels
      • Home
      • Issues
      • Regions
      • Experts
      • Events
      • Publications
      • Publikationen auf deutsch Publications en français
      Shortcuts
      • Judy Dempsey’s Strategic Europe
      • For Media
    • Moscow
      • Home Главная страница
      • Programs Программы
      • Issues Темы
      • Experts Эксперты
      • Events События
      • Publications Публикации
      Shortcuts
      • For Media
    • New Delhi
      • Home
      • Issues
      • Regions
      • Experts
      • Events
      • Publications
      Shortcuts
      • For Media
      • Video
    • Washington
      • Home
      • Issues
      • Regions
      • Publications
      • Experts
      • Events
      • Programs
      • Projects
      Shortcuts
      • Video
      • Infographics
      • For Media
      • For Government
      • For Academics

    Languages

    • English
      • Experts
      • Publications
      • Events
    • Русский
      • Эксперты
      • Публикации
      • События
    • 中文
      • 专家
      • 出版物
      • 会议
    • عربي
      • الباحثون
      • المنشورات
      • الأنشطة
  • Русский
  • Research
  • Events
  • Experts
  • Issues

The BRICS and the West: Partners or Rivals?

Source: Getty
Petr Topychkanov Op-Ed July 8, 2015 Russia Direct
Summary
The BRICS and the West are neither rivals nor partners. The BRICS isn’t challenging the West, but the West’s own growing weaknesses are empowering the BRICS.
Related Topics
  • Nonproliferation
  • New Cold War
Related Media and Tools
  • Print Page
 

The BRICS and the West have neither a rival nor partner relationship. There is no basis for such perceptions between the BRICS and the West. The BRICS is not an alliance. It's not a military bloc. The members of this group don't have any intention to transform it into something formalized.

Topychkanov is an associate in the Carnegie Moscow Center’s Nonproliferation Program.
Petr Topychkanov
Associate
Nonproliferation Program
Moscow Center
More from this author...
  • Pakistan Cannot Influence Russia’s Strategic Partnership With India
  • Nonproliferation Requires More Cooperation Between Russia and the West
  • Premonition of Nuclear Threat
  • Prime Partner
@PTopych
They are not interested in any confrontation with the West, because all of them except Russia have close ties with Western countries. Even Russia, which has problematic relations with many Western countries because of Crimea, is still connected to them via economic, political and cultural links.

The West doesn’t have any reason to see the BRICS as something challenging it. There is only one reason to worry [for the West] – its own growing weaknesses. BRICS was created in response to changes in the world order and global economy.

The space for such an initiative was cleared by Western institutions, which turned out to be unable to play the role that they used to play after the collapse of the Soviet Union. The need for the growth and development of Brazil, China, India, Russia, and South Africa can’t be satisfied with the sole help of the West. These countries’ growth demands injections from many sources.

The BRICS’ economic demands dictate the political agenda for its member states. The group’s creation reflected their understanding the world as polycentric and free of dominance of one center over others.

This understanding is basic for the BRICS. From this point of view, the West is accepted by the BRICS as one of the other centers in international affairs. Those politicians in Western countries who want to secure the West’s superiority over other centers of the world may oppose the BRICS as a manifestation of the world order change.

In short, the more active role of the BRICS is becoming possible because of the growing demands of its member-states and inability of Western institutions to satisfy them.

This article originally appeared in Russia Direct.

End of document
 
Source http://carnegie.ru/2015/07/08/brics-and-west-partners-or-rivals/iezy

More from The Global Think Tank

  • Publications
  • Events
  • Why Do Brazil, Russia, India, and China Need BRICS?
  • China Daily
    Russia Far From Isolated in Non-West Community
  • Another BRIC(S) in the Great Wall
  • Beijing
    The International Order: Present and Future
  • Moscow
    Russia and the West: What Next?
Twitter
@PTopych
@PTopych

Sign up for Carnegie Email

 
  • Connect With Us
  • Support The Global Think Tank
 
Carnegie Moscow Center
 
Please note...

You are leaving the Carnegie–Tsinghua Center for Global Policy's website and entering another Carnegie global site.

请注意...

你将离开清华—卡内基中心网站,进入卡内基其他全球中心的网站。