One of the most striking aspects of the horrific events in Odessa was the image of local police standing idly by as violence around them escalated. Several photographs show unidentified—some have alleged pro-Russian, but who knows?—gunmen firing at their opponents from behind the police cordon, and police officers looking away as if nothing happened. Any normal person will ask, “how is it possible?” But anyone who knows anything about Ukraine will probably ask, “how can it be otherwise?”

Eugene Rumer
Rumer, a former national intelligence officer for Russia and Eurasia at the U.S. National Intelligence Council, is a senior fellow and the director of Carnegie’s Russia and Eurasia Program.
More >

Yulia Latynina, a prominent independent Russian commentator, recently described law enforcement in Donetsk as a “vertical of power” in which local thieves control local police, the Security Service of Ukraine (SBU) controls local thieves, and Russian Federal Security Service (FSB) controls the SBU. It may not be exactly the same in Odessa, but it is probably safe to assume that it is not very different.

Why should it be different in Ukraine’s major port city, where criminal traditions and trade in contraband goods have been a staple of everyday life since the days of Isaak Babel’s “Odessa Tales,” and local thieves and local police have long learned to co-exist as partners? Why should it be different in a country where a government post or a political office is merely a tool of personal enrichment, where the venality of police and law enforcement in general is commonly accepted as a fact of life, where a former president was implicated in an abduction and murder of an opposition journalist, and where a change of government—revolutionary or otherwise—has long meant only that a different team would have the opportunity to steal? Why expect Ukrainian police and law enforcement to be loyal now to the new government when it looks conspicuously like the old government, when the leading contenders in the May 25 presidential election are two politicians of the old school—Petro Poroshenko and Yulia Tymoshenko?

There are many lessons to be learned from this tragedy and from the events of the past six months in Ukraine. One of them is that police reform is just as, if not more important, than military reform. If only Ukraine had competent and professional law enforcement, the lives lost on the Maidan could have been spared, the turmoil in Eastern Ukraine could have been avoided, and who knows what else could have been. That said, nobody has figured out yet how to create honest and professional law enforcement in a thoroughly corrupt state.

By:
  • Eugene Rumer